Mishnah Bava Kamma 1

Authored by: T/N, Joshua Kulp
1:1
ארבעה אבות נזיקים. השור. והבור. והמבעה. וההבער. לא הרי השור. כהרי המבעה. ולא הרי המבעה כהרי השור. ולא זה וזה שיש בהן רוח חיים. כהרי האש שאין בו רוח חיים. ולא זה וזה שדרכן לילך ולהזיק. כהרי הבור שאין דרכו לילך ולהזיק. הצד השוה שבהן שדרכן להזיק. ושמירתן עליך. וכשהזיק חב המזיק לשלם תשלומי נזק במיטב הארץ:
There are four primary causes of injury: the ox and the pit and the crop-destroying beast and fire. [The distinctive feature of] the ox is not like [that of] the crop-destroying beast, nor is [the distinctive feature of] either of these, which are alive, like [that of] fire, which is not alive; nor is [the distinctive feature of] any of these, whose way it is to go forth and do injury, like [that of] the pit, whose way it is not to go forth and do injury. What they have in common is that it is their way to do injury and that you are responsible for caring over them; and if one of them did injury whoever [is responsible] for the injury must make restitution [to the damaged party] with the best of his land.
1:2
כל שחבתי בשמירתו הכשרתי את נזקו. הכשרתי במקצת נזקו חבתי בתשלומין כהכשר כל נזקו. נכסים שאין בהן מעילה. נכסים של בני ברית. נכסים המיוחדים ובכל מקום חוץ מרשות המיוחדת למזיק ורשות הניזק והמזיק. וכשהזיק חב המזיק לשלם תשלומי נזק במיטב הארץ:
Anything that I am responsible to guard, I have rendered it possible to do injury [for which I will become obligated]. If I have partially rendered it possible to do injury, I must make restitution for that injury as if I totally rendered it possible to do injury. When one damages [property that fits all of the following categories]: property that does not have “sacrilege” [i.e. sacrificial animals or property that belongs to the Temple in Jerusalem], property that belongs to other members of the covenant [Jews], property that is owned, and the injury is done in any place other than the private domain of the injurer and the common domain of the injured and injurer, in these cases the injurer must make restitution for the injury with the best of his land.
1:3
שום כסף. ושוה כסף. בפני בית דין. ועל פי עדים בני חורין. בני ברית. והנשים בכלל הנזק. והניזק והמזיק בתשלומין:
Assessment [of injury] in money or things worth money must be made before a court of law and by witnesses that are free and Children of the Covenant (Jews). Women may be parties in [suits concerning] injury. The injured and the injurer [in certain cases may share] in the compensation.
1:4
חמשה תמין וחמשה מועדין. הבהמה אינה מועדת. לא ליגח. ולא ליגוף. ולא לשוך. ולא לרבוץ. ולא לבעוט. השן מועדת לאכול את הראוי לה. הרגל מועדת לשבור בדרך הלוכה. ושור המועד. ושור המזיק ברשות הניזק. והאדם. הזאב. והארי. והדוב. והנמר. והברדלס. והנחש. הרי אלו מועדין. רבי אליעזר אומר בזמן שהן בני תרבות אינן מועדין. והנחש מועד לעולם. מה בין תם למועד אלא שהתם משלם חצי נזק מגופו ומועד משלם נזק שלם מן העלייה:
Five [agents of damage] rank as harmless and five as an attested danger. Cattle are not an attested danger to butt, push, bite, lie down, or kick. The tooth [of an animal] is an attested danger to eat that which is for it; The leg [of an animal] is an attested danger to break [things] as it walks along; So also is a warned ox [an ox that has gored before]; And an ox that damages in the domain of the damaged party, and human beings. The wolf, the lion, the bear, the leopard, the panther and the snake all rank as attested danger. Rabbi Eliezer says: When they are tame they are not attested danger, but the snake is always an attested danger. What is the difference between that which is harmless and that which is an attested danger? The harmless pays half-damages from its own body and the attested danger pays full damages from the best property (of its owner and guardian).

Select a line on the left to view commentary.

Help support Theologa. Click to donate now!

Click a line to discuss

Comments